Pottery Barn Pumpkin Dupes: The Best Terracotta Jack-O'-Lantern Look-Alikes for Less
/Disclosure: This post uses affiliate links. This means that if you purchase something that I feature, I’ll get a small commission (this will not increase the price of the item). Thank you for supporting KFI.
That's where a good Pottery Barn terracotta pumpkin dupe comes in. I went looking for the closest matches to that handcrafted, lime-washed, "found it at a Tuscan pumpkin patch" look — and rounded up 10 of the best ones below, so you can get the Pottery Barn pumpkin aesthetic while staying within your budget.
If terracotta pumpkins have you in a full fall decorating mood, don't miss my easy Halloween decorating ideas that transform your home in minutes, plus my favorite Halloween decor picks for an organic modern home.
What Makes the Pottery Barn Terracotta Jack-O'-Lantern So Popular
Before we get to the dupes, it helps to know exactly what we're copying. Pottery Barn's terracotta pumpkins are:
Handmade from real terracotta clay (not resin or plastic), so each one has natural texture and slight color variation
Hand-carved with a jack-o'-lantern face — simple, not cartoonish
Sold in multiple sizes separately, from small tabletop pumpkins to large statement porch pieces
Finished in that warm, slightly weathered lime-washed terracotta tone that reads more "vintage Italian courtyard" than "Halloween aisle"
Any dupe worth buying needs to nail at least two of those things: the terracotta material (or a very convincing look-alike) and that softer, carved-not-painted face. Every Pottery Barn dupe that you’ll see below has at least both of these things (and many have much more to offer!), so you can pick the item that works best for you.
10 Best Pottery Barn Pumpkin Dupes
If you like the Pottery Barn black terracotta pumpkin, I’ve found a dupe for that too! This one leans into that same moodier, washed-black finish instead of the classic warm orange — great if your fall porch skips traditional orange altogether. It keeps the same handcrafted, carved-face look at a fraction of the Pottery Barn price.
This 2-pack includes one tall and one short pumpkin, each hand-brushed in an antique white wash for that same weathered terracotta look Pottery Barn is known for. Like the Pottery Barn originals, the hollow, carved-face design holds a tea light or LED candle, so these will flicker on the porch at night too, not just sit there.
This 9" diameter, 8" tall pumpkin has the same antiqued, weathered finish and classic carved grin as Pottery Barn's, plus built-in LED lights so it's ready to glow straight out of the box, no separate tea light needed. It's a nice tabletop-sized pick for a mantel, bookshelf, or covered patio.
This medium-size matte black terracotta pumpkin is a great pick if you want the Pottery Barn carved-face look in a moodier, more modern finish. It's a step up in size from the small $5 versions, making it a good middle piece for a graduated display, and it pairs easily with the moss green or off-white small pumpkins for contrast.
This is the one that's been all over TikTok and Instagram for good reason. At just $5 each, these mini terracotta jack-o'-lanterns come in a similar lime-wash finish to Pottery Barn's, with the same carved jack-o'-lantern cutout face.
Marshalls' off-price selection is always a bit of a treasure hunt in stores, but this one is also available online for $20. I love the shape on this one — it's a little more squat and rounded than some of the others on this list, with the same warm terracotta finish and carved face you're after.
Hand thrown by artisans in Vietnam, this pair comes in two shapes, one plump and one tall, with a similar artisanal terracotta finish to Pottery Barn's. Pop an LED candle inside each and they glow just like the original, at a fraction of the price for two.
This one leans into the carved-pumpkin-face look with a rustic terracotta finish and an open-bottom design built to hold a flameless candle for that cozy, glowing look after dark. At roughly 9.5" tall, it's an easy way to add a warm, handcrafted-looking accent to a console table, covered front porch, or entryway.
Styling Tips to Make the Dupes Look High-End
A great dupe still needs the right styling to read as "designer," not "discount." A few tricks that work with any of the pumpkins above:
Mix sizes. Pottery Barn's own vignettes almost never use a single size — group a small, medium, and large together for that layered, collected-over-time look.
Add real or faux stems from other pumpkins. If your dupe's stem looks too uniform, swap in a stem from a natural mini pumpkin for texture.
Keep the color palette narrow. Stick to terracotta, cream, and sage green accents rather than mixing in bright orange plastic pumpkins, which will make the terracotta ones look cheaper by comparison.
Light them at dusk. A simple LED tea light or flameless candle inside any of these pumpkins instantly elevates the look for evening trick-or-treaters.
Cluster, don't line up. Odd-numbered groupings (three or five) clustered together photograph better than a straight row.
Final Thoughts
Whether you go all-in on Target's $5 version, splurge slightly on Wayfair's statement pumpkin, or mix sizes from one of the Walmart or Amazon sets, you can absolutely get the Pottery Barn terracotta pumpkin look this Halloween without the Pottery Barn price tag. My pick for most people: grab a few of the Target dupes for the budget-friendly cluster look, and add one larger Wayfair, Amazon, or Walmart piece as your porch's focal point.
—
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the closest dupe to the Pottery Barn terracotta pumpkin? Target's terracotta jack-o'-lantern is generally considered the closest match in finish and price, thanks to its similar lime-washed terracotta tone and carved face at a fraction of Pottery Barn's cost.
Are the Pottery Barn terracotta pumpkins worth the price? They're genuinely handmade and each one is unique, which is why they carry a higher price tag. If budget isn't a concern, they're a solid splurge — but the dupes above get you 90% of the look for a much smaller investment.
Can I use terracotta pumpkin dupes outdoors? Most terracotta and clay pumpkins (real Pottery Barn included) are meant for covered outdoor areas rather than full sun and rain exposure, since prolonged moisture can cause cracking. Check each listing's care instructions before leaving one uncovered all season.
Where can I buy terracotta pumpkin jack-o'-lanterns for less? Target, Walmart, Wayfair, and Amazon all currently stock terracotta or clay jack-o'-lantern pumpkins in the $5–$60 range, compared to Pottery Barn's $30–$129.
Pottery Barn pumpkin dupes.