the best mcgee and co. molly stool dupes for a modern organic home
/Disclosure: This post uses affiliate links. This means that if you purchase something that I feature, I’ll get a small commission (this will not increase the price of the item). Thank you for supporting KFI.
If you’ve been dreaming about giving your kitchen a Studio McGee–inspired refresh, chances are you’ve seen the McGee & Co Molly Stool in one of their gorgeous projects. With its handwoven seat, warm wood tones, and timeless silhouette, it’s the definition of casual sophistication — the perfect piece for a modern organic kitchen.
But here’s the catch: outfitting your island with four or six Molly Stools can get pricey fast. If you’re like me, you want to create that signature Studio McGee look but at a price that still leaves room in the budget for other home projects. That’s why I searched high and low for the best McGee & Co Molly Stool dupes — lookalikes that give you the same style, texture, and quality at a much lower price point.
I found not one, but three different looks for less and some styling tips so your kitchen feels professionally designed without the splurge.
If you’re decorating on a budget, make sure to check out all of my McGee and Co. dupes.
The Original: McGee & Co Molly Stool
Handwoven Seat: Adds incredible texture and visual interest.
Natural Wood Frame: The warm finish blends beautifully with most kitchen cabinetry.
Timeless Silhouette: Works with everything from coastal to modern farmhouse to California casual design.
If budget isn’t a concern, the Molly Stool is worth every penny. But if you want the same high-end look for less, the following Molly Stool dupes are excellent options.
My Favorite McGee & Co Molly Stool Dupes
These three stools have the same natural, organic feel as the Molly Stool but come in at a much more approachable price point. For easy comparison, prices below are per stool.
The Nathan James Rikki Light Brown Solid Wood & Seagrass Bar Stool is one of my favorite finds because it looks high-end but comes in a set of two — making it much more affordable if you need several.
Design Details: The handwoven seagrass seat is nearly identical in vibe to the Molly Stool, and the light brown wood frame has the same airy, open silhouette.
Comfort Factor: The mid-height back and cream boucle upholstered cushion make these stools comfortable enough for long family dinners or casual entertaining.
Budget-Friendly: Buying in a set of two keeps the price-per-stool lower than most single designer stools.
The My Texas House Bar Stools are another great pick if you’re furnishing on a budget or just need one or two stools.
Clean, Simple Lines: The silhouette is very similar to the Molly Stool, with a natural woven seat that brings in the right amount of texture.
Great Price Point: They are perfect for renters or first-time homeowners who want the McGee & Co look without the investment.
This one is also a nice option if you want to mix and match with other kitchen seating.
If you want something with a slightly more coastal or boho twist, the Bay Isle Home Coastal 25.5" Rattan Counter Stool from Wayfair is beautiful.
Airy, Woven Design: The natural rattan and narrow legs creates an open, beachy feel.
Easy to Style: Works well in kitchens, covered patios, or breakfast nooks.
This stool is great for anyone leaning into the California casual aesthetic with lots of natural materials and laid-back styling.
Why These McGee and Co. Dupes Work
When looking for a McGee & Co Molly Stool dupe, the key is finding a stool that checks these boxes:
Woven Seat or Back: Brings in that handcrafted look.
Light or Natural Wood: Feels timeless and neutral.
Slim Profile: Keeps kitchens feeling open and airy.
Comfortable for Everyday Use: Works for both casual and formal settings.
All three of these dupes hit the mark, giving you a similar design impact to the Molly Stool without overspending.
Styling Tips for Your Molly Stool Dupes
Want to make your space look like it came straight out of a Studio McGee project? Try these ideas:
Add Pendant Lights: Hang two or three oversized pendants above your island to draw the eye upward.
Layer Neutral Textures: Combine stone countertops, wood accents, and soft textiles for a cozy but sophisticated feel.
Mix Materials: Don’t be afraid to mix warm wood stools with painted cabinetry — the contrast can make your space feel custom.
Keep the Palette Light: Sticking with neutral or earthy tones keeps the space looking fresh and modern.
Studio McGee Look for Less
Creating a Studio McGee–inspired kitchen doesn’t have to break the bank. These McGee & Co Molly Stool dupes offer the same warm, woven look at a fraction of the cost — perfect for building a modern organic home you’ll love. Whether you choose the Nathan James set, the budget-friendly Walmart option, or the airy Wayfair stool, you can get the high-end feel without the high-end price tag.
If you’re looking for more McGee and Co. inspired items, check out the Lettie flush mount or this McGee and Co. Gala floor mirror dupe.
—
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why buy a McGee & Co Molly Stool dupe instead of the original?
Dupes allow you to get the designer look for less, which is especially helpful if you need multiple stools for a kitchen island or bar area.
2. Are these dupes good quality?
Each one is made from wood or sturdy rattan and designed to hold up to daily use. Be sure to pay close attention to the reviews for more detailed information and honest feedback.
3. Which dupe is the closest match?
The Nathan James Rikki stool is probably the closest overall match thanks to its woven seagrass seat and light wood frame.
4. Which dupe is the most budget-friendly?
The Walmart woven stool is the most affordable option and still delivers a very similar look.
5. Can these stools work in other rooms?
Absolutely — they work beautifully as extra seating in dining rooms, breakfast nooks, or even covered patios.
6. How many stools should I buy for my island?
A good rule of thumb is to allow about 24–30 inches of space per stool for comfortable seating.
